Manchester United’s Ownership Set Erik Ten Hag Up for Failure

Alan Shearer discusses the challenges faced by Erik ten Hag at Manchester United, including issues with player signings, ownership decisions, and the harsh realities of Premier League management. He also weighs in on Cole Palmer’s rising value, Kieran Trippier’s impact at Newcastle, and Aberdeen’s strong start in Scotland.

Man United Sabotaged by Manager Talks

Erik ten Hag’s time at Manchester United has been difficult from the start, but much of that stems from the club’s own actions. United have underperformed, sitting in 13th place—a situation unacceptable for a club of their stature and financial investment. After suffering humiliating defeats, such as against Tottenham, these upcoming games are critical for avoiding further embarrassment.

Shearer emphasizes that United’s woes are largely self-inflicted, particularly due to their talks with other managers. Over the summer, United engaged in discussions with potential replacements for ten Hag, leaking the news publicly. Though this is within their rights, the situation placed ten Hag in a nearly impossible position. The club’s decision to explore other managerial options before backing him with a contract extension undermined his authority and set a negative tone.

The Ruthless Reality of Premier League Management

Ten Hag’s signings, particularly those from the Eredivisie, have yet to prove themselves in the Premier League. The club’s recruitment strategy hasn’t clicked, and time is a luxury ten Hag doesn’t have. “You either win games or you’re out,” Shearer remarks, underscoring the harsh environment in which Premier League managers operate. Patience is thin when clubs are spending millions, and ten Hag must find results quickly if he is to survive.

United’s identity on the field remains unclear, with inconsistent performances and signings like Antony failing to make an impact. Shearer notes that recruitment is critical, and when it falters, it becomes even harder to succeed in the fast-paced Premier League.

Bruno Fernandes Not to Blame

Shearer also touches on the controversial red card shown to Bruno Fernandes in the match against Spurs, which was later rescinded. While some blame has been directed at Fernandes, Shearer believes it was an unfortunate slip and the wrong call from officials. He defends Fernandes, saying there’s no fault on his part in that incident.

Cole Palmer’s Rising Value

Turning attention to Cole Palmer, Shearer praises the young Chelsea star for his confidence and impact. Palmer’s decision to leave Manchester City and seek regular playing time at Chelsea was brave, and it’s paying off. Shearer estimates that Palmer’s current market value could easily surpass £140 million, a remarkable rise for a player who only recently made the switch.

Shearer admires Palmer’s courage to walk away from a club as dominant as City, seeking more playing time elsewhere. This decision reflects Palmer’s on-pitch personality, full of self-belief and ambition. Shearer draws a parallel to his own experience leaving Newcastle for Southampton at 15, acknowledging the challenges but admiring Palmer’s boldness.

Trippier’s Continued Value to Newcastle

Shearer is pleased that Kieran Trippier remains at Newcastle, praising his experience and value to Eddie Howe’s side. Despite a minor error in their recent match against Manchester City, Trippier’s overall performance was strong, and his presence will be vital as Newcastle push for success this season.

The competition between Trippier and Tino Livramento for the right-back spot is healthy for the club, keeping both players sharp. Shearer notes that as players age, they must continually prove themselves, and Trippier’s experience will be crucial as he faces competition from younger talents.

Aberdeen Could Upset the Balance in Scotland

Shearer highlights Aberdeen’s impressive start to the season in Scotland, winning all 12 of their games under new management. With Celtic and Rangers juggling European commitments, Aberdeen could take advantage and challenge for the Scottish Premiership title. Their unbeaten run has raised eyebrows, and Shearer hopes they can continue to shake things up in Scottish football.

Arsenal’s Champions League Ambitions

Finally, Shearer is full of praise for Arsenal’s Champions League performance, particularly their recent dismantling of PSG. He believes Mikel Arteta’s side is capable of going deep in the competition, especially if they can maintain the form they’ve shown in recent matches.

With Shakhtar Donetsk next in line, Shearer expects Arsenal to secure another win and solidify their position. As long as the Gunners keep their defense healthy, Shearer believes they have what it takes to make a strong Champions League run this season.