Fabian Schär’s first-half penalty helped Newcastle United scrape past League Two side AFC Wimbledon, setting up a clash with Premier League rivals Chelsea in the Carabao Cup. Here are five key takeaways from the match:
Eight Changes, But Few Impress
Manager Eddie Howe made eight changes to the starting lineup from the weekend’s 1-1 draw against Manchester City. Only Fabian Schär, Joelinton, and Harvey Barnes retained their spots, giving opportunities to players like Lloyd Kelly, Sean Longstaff, Joe Willock, and Miguel Almirón. However, few seized the moment, with Almirón being the only standout performer.
Newcastle’s first-half performance was sluggish and disjointed, with the only breakthrough coming from a penalty after Joe Pigott fouled Almirón in the box, allowing Schär to convert. Despite an improved second-half display, Newcastle struggled to create clear chances.
Howe acknowledged the lack of impact from his squad, saying, “Some players didn’t show their best qualities today, especially in attack, and I think they’ll be disappointed with that.”
Osula’s Bright Start
Will Osula, making his first competitive start since his £15 million transfer from Sheffield United, showed promise. The 21-year-old forward displayed pace, height, and work ethic, impressing the fans with his energy and determination. He nearly found the back of the net in the 69th minute, hitting the side netting after a smart spin. Though service to him was limited, Osula’s effort was appreciated, with fans chanting his name throughout the game.
Howe was cautiously optimistic, stating, “He has a lot of potential, but there’s still a lot of work to do.”
Goalkeeping Surprise at Half-Time
In a surprising moment, St James’ Park PA mistakenly announced John Ruddy as replacing Martin Dubravka at half-time, when it was actually Greek goalkeeper Odysseas Vlachodimos who took over. Vlachodimos made his unexpected debut after Dubravka was forced off with a knee injury from a collision earlier in the game. Nick Pope, Newcastle’s first-choice goalkeeper, was unavailable due to a swollen knee.
The inclusion of Vlachodimos caught many by surprise, as Newcastle had reportedly not initially planned to sign him. However, he became part of the £35 million deal that saw Elliot Anderson move to Nottingham Forest, costing Newcastle £20 million. Vlachodimos performed confidently, handling crosses and distributing the ball well.
Wimbledon’s Gratitude for St James’ Park
Originally scheduled to be played at Wimbledon’s Plough Lane, the fixture was moved to St James’ Park due to flooding and damage at Wimbledon’s home ground. In a gesture of sportsmanship, Newcastle donated £15,000 to Wimbledon’s fundraising efforts, and the League Two club will receive 45% of the gate receipts from the 51,000 tickets sold, a significant financial boost compared to their 9,000-seat stadium.
Wimbledon fans showed their appreciation with a “Thank you NUFC” banner before kickoff, a symbol of the goodwill between the two clubs.
Controversial Penalty Decision
Wimbledon manager Johnnie Jackson expressed his frustration with the officiating after the match, particularly the penalty awarded to Newcastle. Jackson accused Schär of diving before Pigott clipped Almirón in the box. Initially, referee Darren Bond waved play on but reversed his decision after consulting with his linesman.
Jackson said, “We’re already underdogs here, we don’t need a linesman stepping in. That decision changed the game, and it’s hard to accept.”
Despite the result, Jackson praised his team’s effort, feeling they had pushed Newcastle to their limits.